
Under the headline, "Has the iPod for Books Arrived?," Slate's Blake Nelson reviews the new Sony eReader. The review seems to mirror most of the others I've so far seen (including the Times one from last week), saying that the device is good but not great, and the last sentence of the review seems to say it all: "But as things stand now, I'll stick to the paperback on my bedside." In my own personal view, I think that expecting an "iPod for publishing" is foolhardy; the iPod was a once-in-a-generation moment, and I doubt publishing will find its equivalent. What publishing needs to work on instead is integration with existing devices, as well as the smaller Utra-Mobile PCs which should catch on a few years (now known as the UMPC).
Excerpt: "What will you get if you, a run-of-the-mill bibliophile, buy the Sony Reader? Well, you'll be getting an understated gadget, styled soberly and about the size and weight of a slim trade paperback. It won't turn heads, and your nephew probably won't be yanking it out of your hands, but it's also a lot more interesting to show off to your friends than the latest Treo."


Comments